Charlotte's Web
by E.B. White
PAIR 1 ANCHOR. Iconic animal-friendship classic. Sets the warm, gentle register of the post.
May 10, 2026
If You Liked This Book, Try This One (Round 2 — May 5 pairings)
If your kid loved this, they will love this.
View this post on Instagram →These are the books featured in this post — tap any cover to find it on Amazon.
The Cricket in Times Square
by George Selden
PAIR 1 COMPANION. Connective tissue: Garth Williams illustrated both — that's the slide hook. Same artist, same gentle register, deeper shelf.
Matilda
by Roald Dahl
PAIR 2 ANCHOR. Smart girl, neglectful adults, books as escape and weapon. Dahl is name-only per standing rules.
The Problim Children
by Natalie Lloyd
PAIR 2 COMPANION. Connective tissue: smart, weird kids vs. absent or adversarial grown-ups. Carly's family favorite. Natalie Lloyd is the only contemporary author in pairs 1-2 — handle to screen.
A Wrinkle in Time
by Madeleine L'Engle
PAIR 3 ANCHOR. Philosophical girl hero, big questions about love and choice across dimensions. L'Engle deceased — name-only.
Tuck Everlasting
by Natalie Babbitt
PAIR 3 COMPANION. Connective tissue: 'two books where you can't tell who needs who more, and that is the whole point' — Carly's read 4/29. The book builds people you fall for in 150 pages and leaves you missing a family that never existed. Babbitt deceased — name-only. Read 4/29, library copy.
Sideways Stories from Wayside School
by Louis Sachar
PAIR 4 ANCHOR. The original 'one weird school' classic — Sachar invented the genre that still echoes through middle-grade humor today. Per Carly's 4/28 ruling, anchor in this format CAN be previously-featured. Sachar contemporary, alive — handle to screen.
The Unlucky Lottery Winners of Classroom 13
by Honest Lee and Matthew J. Gilbert
PAIR 4 COMPANION. Connective tissue: one weird thing breaks the whole class wide open. Sachar invented the genre, Lee and Gilbert are the modern beneficiary — publisher itself markets the series as 'for fans of Sideways Stories from Wayside School.' Read 4/29 — Carly confirmed clean tone, 'just funny little stories.' Caption carries a quick fart-joke aside per 4/29 read. AUTHOR HANDLE: @mattgilbertwrites was published in Gilbert's own bio across multiple platforms but Carly confirmed 4/29 'account doesn't exist' when tagging in Meta. Dropping to name-only. Lee is undisclosed pseudonym, name-only by structure. Tag publisher only.
The Stonekeeper
by Kazu Kibuishi
PAIR 5 ANCHOR. Portal-fantasy graphic novel about siblings against dark forces. Iconic among GN readers. Per Carly's 4/28 ruling, anchor in this format CAN be previously-featured. Publisher CORRECTED 4/29 to Scholastic per Carly's physical book cover. Kibuishi contemporary, alive, very prolific — handle to screen.
Mighty Jack
by Ben Hatke
PAIR 5 COMPANION. Connective tissue: siblings + portal + magical-darkness register; both first-in-series with stronger sequels waiting. Library pickup, read 4/28. First Second handle CORRECTED 4/29: actual Instagram is @01firstsecond (29K followers). Hatke contemporary — handle to screen.
As an Amazon Associate, XO Your Book Fairy earns from qualifying purchases. Bookshop.org links may also earn a commission.